How Industrial Land Scarcity Is Reshaping Site Selection in Emerging Markets
Industrial land scarcity is reshaping site selection in emerging markets, driving businesses to prioritize power, space optimization, and transport access.
Industrial land scarcity is forcing businesses in emerging markets to rethink site selection strategies. Rapid urbanisation, rising demand for data centres, and limited infrastructure are driving competition for available land. Companies now prioritise reliable power, efficient designs, and access to labour and transport over traditional location preferences. Here's a quick summary of how this issue is reshaping decisions:
-
Key Challenges:
- Urban expansion reduces industrial zones.
- High demand for data centres, manufacturing sites, and cold chain logistics.
- Infrastructure gaps and rising land costs.
-
Sector-Specific Impacts:
- Logistics: Need large, well-connected spaces.
- Data Centres: Require reliable power and cooling.
- Manufacturing: Demand specialised setups.
- Cold Chain: Depend on power and proximity to markets.
-
New Priorities:
- Power: Reliable electricity is critical, especially for energy-intensive sectors.
- Space Optimisation: Vertical warehousing and flexible zoning are gaining traction.
- Labour and Transport: Balancing workforce access with transport connectivity.
-
Regional Focus (GCC & MENA):
- Free zones and proximity to ports are key.
- Cooling and water infrastructure are essential for arid climates.
- Cross-border models help mitigate land shortages.
-
Solutions:
- Vertical warehousing.
- Brownfield redevelopment.
- Hub-and-spoke operational models.
- Advanced tools like power mapping, labour analytics, and transport cost modelling.
Businesses must weigh multiple factors and adopt data-driven tools to navigate these constraints effectively. Local market expertise and public–private collaborations are increasingly critical in addressing these challenges.
How Land Scarcity Changes Site Selection
The scarcity of industrial land has reshaped how companies approach site selection. Instead of focusing on finding the "perfect" plot, businesses now prioritise operational necessities and adapt their criteria to navigate land constraints.
Power-First Site Selection
For energy-intensive industries, reliable power has become the top priority in site selection. Unlike in the past, where factors like location or cost might have taken precedence, companies are now laser-focused on securing sites with dependable electrical infrastructure.
Take data centres, for example. These facilities require uninterrupted power and robust backup systems, making areas with pre-existing electrical networks far more attractive. Many businesses are willing to pay extra for sites with energised connections or those that can guarantee faster power hook-ups.
Manufacturing facilities face similar challenges. Operations requiring specialised power setups - such as clean rooms or heavy machinery installations - must prioritise locations with the necessary electrical capabilities. This often means compromising on other factors to ensure the power reliability essential for smooth operations.
Once power needs are addressed, companies turn their attention to making the most of limited space through innovative design and zoning strategies.
Zoning and Space Optimisation
With industrial land becoming both scarcer and more expensive, maximising every square metre has become a critical focus. This has led to significant changes in how facilities are designed and zoned.
Vertical warehousing is one such solution. By building upwards, companies can increase capacity without expanding their footprint. However, this approach requires stronger building foundations, specialised equipment for moving goods vertically, and adjustments to workflow processes.
Enhanced floor area ratios and flexible zoning also play a key role. Negotiating these adjustments can be time-consuming and often involves meeting stricter building codes, but they allow companies to use land more intensively. Flexible zoning, in particular, has proven to be a game-changer. Sites that allow mixed industrial uses - such as combining warehousing, light manufacturing, and office spaces - offer increased versatility and better space utilisation.
Optimising space is only part of the equation. Companies also need to ensure their sites are accessible to workers and transport networks.
Labour and Transport Access
Land scarcity has forced companies to juggle competing priorities, and worker accessibility is now a major consideration. Finding locations that balance operational requirements with practical access for employees has become a key challenge.
Proximity to labour is critical, especially in areas where public transport options are limited or unreliable. Companies must carefully weigh urban distance against worker convenience to maintain a steady and accessible workforce.
Transport infrastructure is equally important. While direct highway access used to be a must-have, many companies are now open to locations with good connections to transport hubs, even if these add some complexity to logistics. The emphasis is on ensuring goods move efficiently, even if the route isn’t the most straightforward.
Balancing proximity to major transport hubs with cost has become a nuanced calculation. Sites within reasonable transport corridors, rather than right next to a hub, can often deliver better overall value while still meeting operational needs.
Ultimately, site selection today requires a far more sophisticated approach. Simple checklists and single-factor decisions no longer suffice. Companies must weigh competing priorities and make trade-offs that were unthinkable when industrial land was more readily available.
Regional Focus: GCC and MENA Requirements
The GCC and MENA regions face distinct challenges, particularly when it comes to industrial land scarcity. Companies in these markets must navigate unique regional factors, including extreme climates and the complexities of operating across multiple regulatory frameworks. These dynamics demand tailored approaches and creative solutions to succeed in the region.
Free Zone and Port Proximity
With industrial land in short supply, free zones play a pivotal role in the GCC. Their regulatory and logistical advantages - such as tax exemptions, streamlined customs processes, and policies encouraging foreign investment - make them highly attractive. For instance, the Jebel Ali Free Zone in the UAE stands out as a prime example, where intense demand has driven competition and prompted many operators to explore secondary zones.
Another key factor in site selection is proximity to major ports and air cargo hubs. Locations near these transport hubs can significantly lower shipping costs, though the premium associated with such connectivity often leads to higher overall expenses. To manage this, many companies adopt a multi-tiered strategy: establishing core operations in prominent free zones while situating secondary activities in areas with more affordable land and leasing options.
Water and Cooling Challenges in Arid Climates
The arid climates of the MENA region bring unique challenges, particularly concerning water scarcity and high temperatures. Industrial facilities and data centres, for example, require efficient cooling systems to maintain operations during peak heat. Access to district cooling systems and reliable water sources can make certain locations more competitive, even if they demand long-term planning.
For industries with high water consumption, being close to dependable water infrastructure is critical. Facilities near desalination plants or equipped with advanced water treatment systems often gain an edge in regions where water is scarce. To expand the range of viable sites, some companies are exploring innovative cooling methods, such as liquid cooling and solutions powered by renewable energy. These strategies not only address environmental constraints but also highlight the importance of regional collaboration to overcome shared challenges.
Cross-Border Collaboration Models
The scarcity of industrial land has pushed companies to adopt cross-border strategies. Many are leveraging a hub-and-spoke model, which allows them to distribute operations across multiple markets and reduce the impact of local land shortages. For instance, businesses are creating primary logistics hubs in well-established free zones within the UAE while setting up secondary distribution centres in neighbouring markets like Saudi Arabia.
Special economic zones in Oman and Bahrain also offer alternative options, often with more affordable leasing terms and enhanced regional connectivity. However, cross-border logistics require meticulous planning to address varying customs regulations, labour laws, and other jurisdictional differences. Despite these hurdles, this distributed approach enables companies to access multiple markets efficiently.
Additionally, shared infrastructure projects, such as planned regional rail networks, are expected to unlock new opportunities for inland industrial development. These initiatives could further ease the pressure of land scarcity and enhance connectivity across the region.
Strategies to Address Land Scarcity
As land becomes increasingly scarce in emerging markets, businesses are finding creative ways to make the most of limited space. From building upwards to repurposing old sites, these strategies are helping companies adapt to the challenge of land constraints.
Vertical Warehousing and Multi-Storey Solutions
One effective way to tackle space shortages is through vertical warehousing. These multi-storey facilities, equipped with truck-accessible ramps, are designed to maximise storage on smaller plots of land. By integrating automated systems for storage and retrieval across multiple levels, businesses can streamline operations while saving space. Typically, the ground floor handles logistics, while the upper levels focus on storage and fulfilment.
What’s more, modular vertical designs allow for future expansion upwards rather than outwards, which is particularly useful as business needs grow. While the initial investment for such facilities is higher, the long-term cost per square metre often proves more economical in areas with soaring land prices. For industries like pharmaceuticals and food distribution, temperature-controlled vertical warehouses are increasingly necessary, featuring advanced HVAC systems to maintain consistent conditions across all levels.
Brownfield Redevelopment
Another smart approach is repurposing existing industrial sites, also known as brownfield redevelopment. These sites often come with pre-existing infrastructure, which can speed up project timelines and reduce costs compared to starting from scratch on undeveloped land.
However, environmental remediation is often required, and this can vary significantly depending on the location. To encourage redevelopment, many governments in emerging markets offer incentives like tax breaks and faster permitting processes. Former manufacturing sites, for example, are particularly well-suited for modern uses such as data centres or logistics hubs, thanks to their robust electrical systems and adaptable loading areas.
Regional Hub-and-Spoke Models
For businesses looking to optimise operations despite land constraints, a hub-and-spoke model offers a practical solution. This strategy involves placing core activities in premium, well-connected locations while using satellite facilities in more affordable areas for secondary functions like bulk storage and regional distribution. This setup helps reduce overall real estate costs without sacrificing efficiency.
In some cases, businesses even take advantage of cross-border arrangements, leveraging differences in costs and regulations between neighbouring markets. Success in this model relies on unified logistics platforms for real-time coordination and dependable transport infrastructure. Long-term partnerships with logistics providers and built-in supply chain redundancy are also key to managing potential disruptions effectively.
Tools and Methods for Site Selection
When land becomes scarce and prices soar, selecting the right site demands precision and data-backed decisions. Modern tools help businesses navigate these challenges, offering insights that simplify the complexities of land scarcity and operational planning.
Power and Infrastructure Mapping
For energy-intensive industries like data centres or manufacturing, grid capacity mapping is often the starting point. This process involves creating detailed maps that highlight electrical grid capacity, substation locations, and power availability in specific areas. To achieve this, companies often collaborate with utility providers to access grid heat maps, which pinpoint areas requiring upgrades.
Another essential consideration is substation proximity analysis, which helps businesses estimate connection costs and timelines. Sites within 2 kilometres of substations typically offer quicker connections and lower infrastructure costs. On the other hand, remote sites may require significant investments for new transmission lines and equipment.
Utility connection timelines also play a key role, especially in emerging markets. Well-established industrial zones can often provide connections within 3 to 6 months, while remote locations might face delays of 12 to 18 months. Advanced site selection tools now incorporate these timelines into cost-benefit analyses, allowing businesses to account for both direct expenses and the opportunity costs of delayed operations.
In arid regions, such as the GCC, water infrastructure mapping is equally critical. Businesses rely on desalination capacity maps to locate areas with stable water supplies, essential for cooling systems and industrial processes.
Labour and Transport Analytics
Workforce accessibility mapping uses isochrone analysis to illustrate travel times from residential areas to potential sites. These maps divide areas into 30-minute, 45-minute, and 60-minute travel zones, helping businesses gauge their labour pool. Locations with broader workforce catchments often provide better recruitment opportunities and reduce the need for wage premiums.
Skills density analysis overlays workforce data with geographic information to identify regions rich in specific technical expertise. For example, logistics companies might focus on areas with a strong presence of warehouse and transport workers, while data centres would prioritise locations with skilled electrical and IT technicians.
Transport cost modelling evaluates the total logistics expenses for each site. This includes factors like road transport costs, port fees, and cross-border charges. The models also account for seasonal changes, fluctuations in fuel prices, and potential disruptions along transport routes.
Connectivity scoring assesses how well a site links to major transport networks. Factors include proximity to motorways, airports, and rail systems. Sites with strong connectivity often justify higher land prices by offering reduced long-term transport costs.
These tools collectively provide businesses with a strategic approach to site selection, even in challenging conditions.
Risk Scoring and Multi-Criteria Analysis
Beyond infrastructure and labour considerations, regulatory certainty frameworks evaluate the stability and predictability of local regulations. These frameworks score factors like permit processing times, frequency of regulatory changes, and policy consistency. Established free zones often score higher due to their streamlined processes and reliable regulatory environments.
An infrastructure deliverability assessment examines whether promised infrastructure improvements are likely to be completed on time. This involves analysing government budgets, contractor reliability, and project timelines. Sites dependent on future developments often carry higher risks compared to those with existing infrastructure.
Multi-criteria decision analysis brings all these elements together into a weighted scoring system. Businesses assign different weights to factors based on their priorities. For instance, a data centre operator might prioritise power infrastructure, while a logistics company would focus more on transport connectivity.
Finally, scenario planning tools allow businesses to test how different sites might perform under various future conditions, such as rising fuel prices, regulatory shifts, or infrastructure delays. Sites that consistently perform well across multiple scenarios are often the safer choice, even if initial costs are higher.
While these tools provide detailed data and insights, local market knowledge remains equally important. Understanding local practices, business culture, and informal networks is vital for successful site selection, particularly in emerging markets. Combining quantitative analysis with on-the-ground expertise ensures the best outcomes.
Conclusion: Managing Land Scarcity in Emerging Markets
The issue of industrial land scarcity is reshaping how companies approach site selection in emerging markets. With vacancy rates hitting record lows - major markets are seeing rates of 2.9%, while Toronto reports availability at less than 1.0% - the situation is becoming increasingly challenging. To make matters more pressing, industrial construction starts are expected to drop by 60% in 2023 compared to the previous year. This tightening supply is forcing businesses to rethink traditional strategies.
To navigate these challenges, companies are adopting three key adjustments. First, they’re extending project timelines by an additional 90–180 days. Second, they’ve expanded site searches to areas 45–60 minutes away from major transport hubs, compared to the previous 30-minute limit. Finally, they are standardising build-to-suit solutions to better meet their needs. These changes require precise, data-driven decision-making to ensure success.
Tools like data mapping, labour market analytics, and multi-criteria analysis are becoming indispensable in this environment. When paired with local expertise and a thorough understanding of regional conditions, these tools provide sharper insights and better outcomes in tight markets.
Public–private partnerships are emerging as a critical solution for driving new industrial development. With private developers pulling back from speculative projects due to rising interest rates and market uncertainty, collaboration between governments and industries is becoming a necessity. This is especially true in arid GCC markets, where unique challenges such as water scarcity, cooling demands, and complex regulations require joint efforts to build much-needed industrial capacity.
FAQs
How can companies in energy-intensive industries ensure reliable power while meeting other site selection needs?
Companies aiming for reliable power supply should prioritise locations with a well-developed power infrastructure and sufficient grid capacity. Industrial zones in the UAE, for example, are equipped with advanced energy systems that cater to these requirements. Additionally, integrating renewable energy options like solar or wind - guided by thorough geospatial studies - can not only boost energy reliability but also help cut operational costs.
By merging dependable infrastructure with sustainable energy practices, businesses can reduce risks, improve efficiency, and align with the UAE's ongoing commitment to infrastructure growth and advancements in energy solutions.
What strategies are businesses using to optimise industrial land use in emerging markets?
Businesses in emerging markets are finding creative ways to tackle the challenge of limited industrial land. One standout solution is vertical warehousing, where companies build upwards to optimise the use of available space. Another approach is the development of multi-use facilities that combine logistics, storage, and commercial operations under one roof, boosting efficiency while keeping costs in check.
There's also a growing trend of repurposing existing buildings for industrial use, a practice known as adaptive reuse. Additionally, regional collaboration models, which involve businesses sharing infrastructure, are becoming increasingly common. These strategies not only help offset the rising costs of land but also play a key role in advancing essential industries like logistics, warehousing, and data centres in the region.
How do environmental challenges like water scarcity and extreme climates in the GCC and MENA regions impact site selection and operations?
Environmental challenges like water scarcity and extreme climates heavily influence how industrial sites are chosen and managed across the GCC and MENA regions. To combat water shortages, many facilities depend on desalination technologies, water recycling systems, and drought-resistant infrastructure. These solutions directly shape where industrial sites are located and how they are designed.
The region’s intense heat and arid desert conditions also demand robust investments in climate-resilient infrastructure. This includes advanced cooling systems, energy-efficient building designs, and effective thermal insulation. These adaptations are crucial to maintaining smooth and sustainable operations despite environmental pressures. For businesses operating in these markets, addressing these challenges isn’t optional - it’s essential for long-term success.